Home > game, guys, women > Why I Am No Longer Using The 10-Point Rating System

Why I Am No Longer Using The 10-Point Rating System

November 5th, 2009 Leave a comment Go to comments

Don’t get me wrong, nothing is more universal than the 10-point rating system for women and whoever came up with it deserves, at the very least, an Apple “Think Different” poster. He is also, easily, on my Top 5 list of people’s whose hand I would like to shake.

Ever since I learned how to count, I have applied the 10-point rating system to every woman I see, meet, get with, and break up with. If I’m having a difficult time describing how fine the woman I saw at the supermarket was, I give her a number. “Maaaaan, she was at least a 9,” I’ll tell my boys. If I met a woman under the influence in a dimly lit bar only to meet her again for lunch in a well-lit eatery, and she looks drastically different than how I remember, again, I go to the 10-point rating system.  “Maaaan, when I met her, I could’ve sworn she was at least an 8. Then we had lunch, and it turns out she’s a 6.5 and I’m only giving her the point-five because she went dutch with me.”

Yes, for me, the 10-point rating system has been like a calculator — a shortcut to the grand total of a woman’s specific perfections and flaws. Thing is, every man’s calculator is wired differently, which is why I am moving to a 5-point rating system.

The problem with the 10-point system is I have never gone past a 6, and when I did, it was never a compliment because all it really ever said was, “Only on my drunkest, loneliest night.” Thus, if I haven’t ever really gone past a 6, what are numbers 1-5 for? On a scale of 1-10, I never go lower than a 5, because I know it would only make me a 10-point jerk. Only once have I heard a man go to a 5, and as I recall, it was because she had nine toes and a bad weave, which is totally unfair. Every woman has a bad weave once or twice in her life, that is no reason to give her a 5.

This is why a 5-point rating system is more than adequate, because with it, lines are clearly drawn. Allow me to break it down:

1 - I would never ever

2 – I would never

3 – I would, probably, maybe (It should be noted, most women will fall here)

4 – I would

5 – I would right now, tomorrow, and if we would’ve met yesterday, then, too.

See how easy that is?

Not only does the 3 help make a clear distinction between the haves and the wishes-they-had-its, but for the haves, it cuts down on a lot of the hyperbole men usually like to give to women who are an 8 and above on the 10-point scale.

No man would do something to a 10, they wouldn’t do to an 8, and the difference between an 8, 9, and 10 usually comes down to something outside of looks, like how good she can make a grilled cheese sandwich. The other problem with a 10? Whenever a man gives it to a woman, it only encourages his friends to pick said 10 apart brutally, which is unfair to her.

If anything, I am now reserving the 10 for those women who, on the old rating system, I called an 11. On the 5-point system, those women — the Halle Berry-types I only see every few months or so — can be given a 10, which is to say, they’re twice as fine as any 5 I see.

This system is much better.

Someone needs to get me an Apple Think Different poster too.

Categories: game, guys, women Tags:
  • http://20andcounting.wordpress.com 20andcounting

    I should probably start using a rating system for my online dates…I’d say most would probably be a 2 if I were to use your 5 point scale lol. I agree that going all the way up to 10 leaves a lot of room for misinterpretation and what’s really the difference between a 6.5 and a 7?

  • Ashley

    As a woman, I’ve never used a number point ranking system and wonder if there are any women who do?

    Most women I know use the criteria system, in which men have to meet the initial checklist. What’s more different is every woman ranks her criteria in a different order. The usual checklist includes looks/attractiveness, money/employment, intelligence, creativity, sex and swagger/confidence. These can fall in any order for any given woman and for the most part if a man meets the first three on a woman’s list he’s the equivalent of a 5/6/7 on the 10-point rating system guys use. If he hits all of the points then it’s the same as 8/9/10. If he hits less than three, most likely he’s in friend or buddy status and we’re moving on to the next.

  • Kate

    Seriously? You need to get a job soon, cause this is just ridiculous and unnecessarily arrogant because you at the moment are a 5.

  • http://manamongboys.com TrueMan

    I think you need the 10 point system because there still some degrees of what you would of wouldn’t do 1-5. 1 is like Rosanne Barr (never eva..eva, eva, eva, eva). A 3 might be something like a midget in a cowboy hat or something (usually wouldn’t even think twice about it, but it might be fun in a twisted sort of way.)

    Once you get to 5, then you get to where you start seriously considering things.

  • BrwnButterfly

    @Kate:Is that a 5 on the old system or the new one? Those of us reading want to know..:0)

  • oc

    I am a female and I use the number system all the time. There is 1-10 on looks and 1-10 on personality, giving an average score. Jayz for example 3 or 4 on looks, 10 on swag, gives him a solid 7.

  • Leah J

    Why do you need degrees of “would not”? If you won’t, does they why really matter? You just ain’t. Plus, someone (several at that) HAVE done Roseanne Barr, so that just highlights the flaw in that rationale.

    I can’t believe I’m even talking about this. *lol*

  • http://manamongboys.com TrueMan

    Because there are some that you absolutely “would not” and then there are the “would not” unless you could keep it an absolute secret, and so on. It’s not black and white.

  • http://manamongboys.com TrueMan

    So this is a weighted score? LOL – not a bad idea.

  • Kate

    LOL!

  • Dana

    We’re still rating people using a 10 (or 5) point scalepost high school? Who knew?

  • http://zmwright.com zmwright.com

    change #2 to “your pushing it and I’m not inclined unless she makes the first and second move plus has a [insert your redeeming feature here]” and I’m ALL for your system.

  • BrwnButterfly

    Seriously speaking though I gotta keep it real….I have never met a guy that was a 10…8 maybe but never a 10…so I think that the new point system is good. I like it. Girls rate guys too. We’re just much more cruel than guys could ever be. BTW…..I like your blog a lot and I read it faithfully….You sir on a scale of 1 to f are a 6!

  • Zorah_Hahn

    @ Kate…Way to kick a man while he’s down! That was harsh, don’t cha think? Could it be that maybe he struck a nerve? I’m trying to figure out why you were so offended…..anyway, blogs are supposed to be a means by which people can express their personal thoughts no matter how crass or unconventional they may be. With that said…..There’s no crying in baseball!!! If you don’t like what he said, then you can always unsubscribe and start your own…..I’m just sayin’

  • BrwnButterly

    @Zora: Wowzers!! Loving the, “There’s no crying in baseball” quote!!!

  • Sugar

    You are still a d.b…. I hope we never come across each other in real life. I would never want to be subjected to your penis’ “system”. I predict you will never get married…

  • Zorah_Hahn

    @ all of the people taking this WAYYYYY too personally…I am just amazed at how sensitive you’re being!! What’s REALLY going on???

  • BrwnButterly

    Well you know the saying a hurt dog will yelp? I think he just pulled somebody’s card and now they’re angry. I think it’s great!!

  • SpanishJewel

    I have a system, but it’s not based on points. It’s more like “file cabinet” numbering.
    My girls understand the meaning of each code by the number of fingers I flash over to them with my hand in the middle of the dance floor, bar, or wherever it is that we are…and the guy has no clue it’s about him!

    #1- Hot. Would sleep with him on the spot. No questions asked.
    #2- Cute, but not hot enough to sleep with. Filed as a “maybe” (if he plays his cards right)
    #3- Cute, but only as a friend. Nothing more.
    #4- WTF? Over my dead body. No way. No how.

  • http://www.5oh7.com Jen

    Hmm, but with men, wouldn’t 90% of women fall into category 4? Maybe not, “I would do it with pride” but you have to be a real mudduck that a man won’t even one-off you under the cover of darkness, no?

  • LinZ

    Sorry never had a bad weave… do like this post…